RAHUL GANDHI’S TRYST WITH DESTINY?

by Scott Mclaughlan 

On the 11th December, as many observers of Indian politics have long expected, Rahul Gandhi was confirmed as president of the Indian National Congress while out campaigning in Gujarat. He will be officially sworn in on the 16th December.

During the 2014 Indian election campaign, the leader of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), Narendra Modi, successfully lampooned the Congress Party for its “anti-democratic dynastic culture”, deriding Rahul Gandhi as an “egoist prince”. The Congress, Modi claimed, was an orgy of decadence, corruption and unaccountability, that was out of touch with ‘the people’. This ruse appears to have chimed with the Indian electorate: the BJP stormed to victory with the Congress registering its worst ever performance.

In a time when India faces urgent socio-economic and environmental challenges, thus far neglected by the BJP, the decision to install the latest scion of the Nerhu-Gandhi dynasty (1) suggests that the Congress is devoid of ideas, out of touch with the lives of common folk, and perhaps, is a party in terminal decline.

the decision to install the latest scion of the Nerhu-Gandhi dynasty suggests that the Congress is devoid of ideas

Rather curiously, the vast majority of political commentators do not appear to have joined the dots between the political situation in India and the global crisis of social democracy and political parties of the centre-left.

An extraordinary instance of this crisis is the rapid decline of the once mighty French Socialist Party. Following a pitiful return of just 31 MPs in the June 2017 elections (compared to 284 sitting MPs pre-election) financial disaster has forced the party to sell their upmarket headquarters in Paris’ Left Bank, a truly spectacular collapse of “la gauche caviar” indeed.

(Congress Vice President, soon to be President, Rahul Gandhi | PTI)

The Indian National Congress achieved a spectacular victory against arguably the most powerful empire of modern times, achieving independence in 1947. Yet initial achievements withstanding, the radicalism of the national movement was quickly reigned in as the Congress took power. An alliance between Indian capitalists and the upper echelons of the party emerged to dominate the Indian state, locking the potential for radical social transformation firmly in place.

India’s first Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, made significant achievements in the realm of foreign policy. A highly influential figure in the formation of the Non-Aligned Movement, he argued for an ethical internationalism and the right of newly independent countries to peaceful development, without the interference of the cold war great powers.

the radicalism of the national movement was quickly reigned in as the Congress took power

Nonetheless, the radical action needed to address extreme poverty and inequality – a hangover of British colonialism as much as a result of the new economic realities of the post-war world – through the redistribution of wealth, collective rights to resources and much needed action on caste, gender, and minority discrimination, failed to materialise. Nehru’s political actions did not live up to his lofty intellectual ideals of a socially just independent India.

By the mid-1970s as global economic crisis began to bite and neoliberal economics became the only game in town, the Congress had become a highly centralised monolith riddled with corruption, lacking any workable political vision – and perhaps the political will – to deal with the urgent political and socio-economic injustices of modern Indian society. Rahul Gandhi does not represent a break, but continuity with the disappointing legacy of the Congress.

(Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) flag, via timesofindia)

In contemporary times, as political commentators urge Rahul Gandhi to develop a coherent party identity and political message in order to challenge the dominance of the BJP, it is worth asking if the political fortunes of the Congress rest on Rahul Gandhi’s individual gifts, or the political course that India’s oldest party has chosen to navigate?

The fate and future of another two old giants of the centre-left offer some clues here. The failure of the US Democratic Party to break with the neoliberalism of the Obama years, backing Hillary Clinton at the expense of Bernie Sanders was ultimately disastrous for the party. Perhaps most shocking of all was that the Democrat “high command” appear to have been more fearful of a Sanders victory, than the prospect of a Tangerine Tornado descending on the White House, and the wreckage this would inevitably entail.

Perhaps most shocking of all was that the Democrat “high command” appear to have been more fearful of a Sanders victory, than the prospect of a Tangerine Tornado descending on the White House

On the other hand, as Richard Seymour has astutely pointed out, the grass-roots reinvigoration of the left in the UK, that carried Jeremy Corbyn to the Labour leadership, has effectively saved the party from almost certain collapse, and the terminal electoral decline that has beset its European counterparts in the Netherlands, France, Germany and beyond.

Coronation of the Congress Party’s “crown prince” may well do the trick and provide serious opposition to the BJP. Rahul Gandhi may prove adept at the alliance building tactics essential for victory in the coming Indian state elections. That being said, a quick glance at the state of centre-left politics the world over suggests that abdication might be a better strategy. If the Indian National Congress is to win “hearts and minds”, become relevant to the needs of the Indian people, and alert to the huge challenges of the twenty first century, it must be reinvigorated from the grass-roots up.

(1) Unprecedented in the history of modern democracy, the Nehru-Gandhi political dynasty spans seven generations. However, the key figures are: Jawaharlal Nehru (1889–1964) India’s first Prime Minister; Indira Gandhi (1917–1984), daughter of Nehru and India’s first female Prime Minister; Rajiv Gandhi (1944–1991) son of Indira and former Indian Prime Minister. Both Indira and Rajiv were assassinated. The latest edition is Rahul Gandhi (1970-) son of Rajiv and his widow Sonia Gandhi (1946-), the former president of the Indian National Congress.

Featured image: via indialivetoday


The Norwich Radical is non-profit and run by volunteers. All funds raised help cover the maintenance costs of our website, as well as contributing towards future projects and events. Please consider making a small contribution and fund a better media future.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.